It has been 17 years and 210 days since the city’s pledge to build the West Branch Library.
Nearly all major battles we face seem to revolve around either love or money. In the case of the Coyotes vs. Glendale it’s definitely money. Before I post a blog on the current deal between these entities it’s important to understand the effects of the biggest driver — money.
Westgate and its sales tax revenue is an important component. It cannot be denied that the majority driver of retail sales tax revenue in Westgate comes from Tanger Outlets. Before Tanger’s opening in November of 2012 retail sales tax revenue was under a million dollars a year. Tanger, when it opened, was projected to earn $2M in sales tax revenue and in fact, from the start, has generated closer to the $2.5M mark.
As you can see from the chart below in calendar years 2013 and 2014 retail sales tax revenue was over $3.5M and almost all of it is attributable to Tanger. In October of 2014 Tanger expanded and the city can now expect an estimated $4.5M in retail sales tax revenue in 2015. Restaurant/Bar sales tax revenue has also increased over time and can be related to football games, hockey games and concerts held at the University of Phoenix Stadium and the Gila River Arena. This component is also attributable to the opening of new restaurants in Westgate. This sales tax revenue has grown as well and is estimated to earn some $3M. “Other” sales tax revenue is composed of bed tax, AZSTA stadium city sales tax, licenses & permits, etc. It is estimated to earn about $5M in 2015.
In 2015 estimated sales tax revenue from Westgate looks like this: Retail — $4 to $4.5M; Restaurant/Bar — $3 to $3.5M; and “Other” — $4.5 to $5M.
The argument often used by Coyotes’ supporters is that the spillover effect from 42 nights of hockey games is essential to Westgate’s restaurants and bars survival and to the city. How much of that spillover is from 70,000 fans attending each of 10 football games? Admittedly it is substantial and could account for anywhere from 1/3 to ½ of the sales tax revenue generated from restaurants and bars annually.
The point is that Westgate has grown despite all of the drama and turmoil of the Coyotes and is strong enough to survive with or without them. If one looks at all of the factors that determine annual sales tax generation at Westgate the Coyotes (from hotel stays and restaurants/bars) are estimated at driving about $2M a year out of a total estimated annual sales tax revenue of a low of $11.5M to a high of $13M.
As long as we are on the subject of money there is another factor to consider. Many Coyotes fans are hoping that the Coyotes will move to downtown Phoenix or a new arena at Talking Stick. Dan Bickley in a recent July 26, 2015 Arizona Republic story entitled Coyotes not out of the woods – or Glendale – just yet said, “Sarver says his Suns pay $23 million a year just to play at US Airways Center: $12 million in debt service, $8 million in arena management costs and $3 million in rent. A new arena capable of housing a NBA team and a NHL franchise starts at $500 million, and that’s being conservative.” Kudos to Robert Sarver for publicly offering some expense figures (no revenue figures, mind you). That’s more than anyone has seen from the Coyotes. Any public figures associated with the Coyotes have been minimized or denied by Anthony LeBlanc, an owner and visible spokesperson for the ownership group.
The question for the Coyotes becomes can they afford to move anywhere? Sarver is not in the charity business and I suspect that the owners of Talking Stick are not either. All bets are off if the Coyotes move out of Arizona. Is there an entity out there willing to pay the Coyotes to play in a newly constructed arena? Who knows? The Coyotes will have to pay to play anywhere else in Arizona and as long as they continue to suffer losses of an undetermined amount their options are very limited. No one is offering any love to the Coyotes these days and their entire future is being driven by only one thing – money.
© Joyce Clark, 2015
FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which is in accordance with Title 17 U.S. C., Section 107. The material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law and who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use,’ you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
The Coyotes MUST leave Glendale in order to survive.
It all revolves around TUESDAY and THURSDAY nights.
The fans don’t come out in sufficient numbers.
Leblanc tried to explain to all fans of NHL hockey that he needed participation from the fans in order to succeed.
The fans blew him off and kept up with the “location” excuses.
The number 1 problem is that there are hockey fans living right here in Phoenix who back other teams and will not participate in supporting, in any way, NHL hockey in the town that they live in……Phoenix.
They go to one game a year, scream against the Coyotes and your standing behind them the next morning in a line at Fry’s.
The second problem are the proclaimed Coyote fans who constantly give the “location” excuse for not attending the games..
Never mind the fact that despite all of this, the arena fills up to over 80% capacity on average for the year (don’t tell me about inflated numbers..ALL the teams do that)
However these numbers WILL NOT change unless we move.. Before moving: FIRST, the team should do a season ticket pre-sale.
To find out if the fans who complain about location all the time, would actually come if they did move or is it just talk.
If they don’t get over 13000 season tickets purchased in the pre-sale….They should move out of state.
It is important for this state NOT to lose ANY professional organization, be it sporting teams, symphony orchestras, museums or any other source of community pride.
I don’t know how many people there are like me, but I actively avoid the Westgate area -because- of the sports facilities. I don’t want to forget a game day and end up in stadium or arena traffic. And when you avoid game days, it’s just as easy to avoid all the other days as well. (Arrowhead is a lot closer, and I don’t remember ever getting into any traffic problems from the Peoria Sports Complex.
I think I’ve been to the Cabela’s at Westgate once, and once to one of the smaller strip malls in the same area to put in a job application. (Which I’m a little relieved I didn’t get hired for.)
Truth be told, I enjoy Westgate, the restaurants, Tanger, Cabelas, etc…WHEN there are no games. It’s a nicely developed area, I think the Coyotes have left their stink there. I could care less if the Coyotes go or stay, secretly I hope they go so this drama will end.