Disclaimer: The comments in this blog are my personal opinion and may or may not reflect an adopted position of the city of Glendale and its city council.
Voluntarily staying home has allowed me the time to think about this situation…a lot. As a councilmember it is my primary duty to protect the residents of Glendale. On a personal level, I am the primary caregiver for my 84 year old husband, a 90 year old brother-in-law and a 76 year old brother. If I get sick they have no one else. These are my random thoughts about this situation. I’d love to have your thoughts as well as a comment to this blog.
- With increased testing the number of people diagnosed with the virus will rise dramatically. Many probably already had symptoms or were mildly ill and the tests will merely confirm their illness.
- Social distancing has become critical. You may be young and healthy and may not care about social distancing but you should care…deeply. What if you are asymptomatic? You have no symptoms but turn out to be a carrier. Do you want to take the chance of giving it to an aunt or uncle? Your grandmother or grandfather? There is a difference between thinking you are immortal and selfishness. Granted, nothing may happen to you but there could be many people who may suffer as a result of your action or perhaps, inaction.
- The City of Flagstaff has just declared a State of Emergency. It has a population of 138,000 (roughly half that of Glendale) and ranks as the 15th largest city in the state. What prompted them to declare? Should the ten largest cities in the state (Phoenix, Tucson, Mesa, Chandler, Scottsdale, Glendale, Gilbert, Tempe, Peoria and Surprise) be making the same declaration?
- Hoboken, New Jersey, with a population of about 50,000 has declared a curfew for the entire town from 10 PM to 6 AM. What made them decide to do so? Many cities nationwide are mandating the closure of all public gathering places such as restaurants, theaters, gatherings of people, etc. What caused them to do so?
- As Dr. Anthony Fauci stated very recently, “If it looks like you’re overreacting you’re probably doing the right thing.” Personally, I think Glendale should be overreacting. I think it is time for Glendale to become proactive by mandating the closure of all businesses with the exception of pharmacies, grocery stores, banks and gas stations.
- Why when we have council meetings are we still allowing the public to attend? Why are we not taking the temperatures of employees when they come to work? If they have a fever they should be sent home and self quarantine for 14 days.
- Fauci talks repeatedly about “flattening the curve.” What he means is that if we social distance and contain the spread, our local health systems will not be over whelmed. We know there is a limited supply of Personal Protective Gear (PPE) for first responders as well as ventilators for the sickest. In order to preserve these limited resources cities throughout the country, including Glendale, should be taking extraordinary measures; to do their part to contain the spread thereby preserving our limited capacity to deal with thousands of sick people…that will soon be here.
- First responders in Glendale should be tested often. Fire personnel will respond with full PPE as long as they can obtain it but police officers will not be wearing that type of protection. How do we protect them?
There is far more that I could say but I would rather have your thoughts. What should Glendale be doing? If anything?
Here’s a dilemma for you that I’d love to have you weigh in on. This Tuesday, Glendale’s city council will have a budget workshop in city hall chambers, open to the public. Should we be meeting in person or should we be telecommuting? We possess that capability.
© Joyce Clark, 2020
FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which is in accordance with Title 17 U.S. C., Section 107. The ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law and who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such material. For more information go to http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use,’ you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Joyce, as leader of the city I would have expected the mayor to go on chaeel 11 or somehow work with marketing to calm people down. No need to buy out water, city water is great and wont be turned off. No need to create shortages of toilet paper, no one needs more than 3 or 4 weeks supply, max. That’s part of leadership and I have not seen him or any other Mayors address those topics. People just need to use common sense so as not to expose the vulnerable.
Common sense goes out the window when people panic.
As can be seen by the panic buying that is going on right now.
While it might be good to close some businesses who will pay those workers not making money especially when bills are due?
Advise everyone over 50 to telecommute and make that option available. As for attending in person, if usually a low turnout, space seating at least 6 feet apart if possible.
But the best bet would be canceling live interaction and use the telecommuting option for all.
Remember we might be able to laugh if we find out we overreacted.
That’s better than crying because we underreacted and seen loved ones pay the price.
Like Jim Moran, I think telecommuting is appropriate for all that have the capability but with no age imposed. Those under 50 might not get sick but they might carry the germ to somebody who can.
Excluding the public from council meetings would be a wise thing thing to do unless everybody attending could be screened before entering, but I don’t think the city has enough equipment to do so.
Shuttering businesses may be a good idea but is it economically feasible, as mentioned by Mark D? (Not me)
Joyce, I don’t know about Flagstaff but what does declaring an emergency do? Free up money from somewhere? Then what?
It would be nice if something could be done about people buying large amounts of “stuff” and then reselling it at inflated prices. Just great- when America is hit with a crisis, what do Americans do? They stick it to their fellow citizens for a few bucks. I’m disgusted by these low-life’s.
End of rant…
I have believed that the nation because of the media has overacted and put so much fear in people. this caused a panic to load up on supplies which the stores should have put a limit on. Yes it may be better to overreact if people would use some common sense.
Closing businesses will definitely hurt the workers pocketbooks and put them in a financial hardship.
Canceling meetings that can be aired over TV should definitely be done or at least postponed a few weeks.
This whole issue of the flu is going to cause a recession and many workers losing their homes.
Interesting fact is over 11,000 people died last year in USA of a flu virus and not much was said. We have 57 or so people die of coronavirus and now we in a Ntional Emergency. If people have a cold or any symptoms get tested and stay home please.
Yeah, someone has to stop the freak out factor going on. This in not a globally fatal killer bug. Yes, people have died from it but there is a high chance that those same people would have died from a flu or measles or other virus. How many people have died from those bugs in the same time frame? Why is no one putting it in perspective? yes it’s contagious, maybe more so than other similar viruses but treat it the same.
If you are at risk or live with someone at risk, the stay home.
If you are even semi-sick from anything, stay home. You should do this anyway.
Do NOT tell EVERYONE to stay home because it won’t happen anyway. Let’s freak out the sheep and empty the stores and kill the economy because a handful of people get the sniffles. H1N1 was a worse bug and we never even got close to this level of hysteria.
Stop putting the drama players into the mix. Relax people. This isn’t the plague!
Doug, you are correct. In 2009 the H1N1 had more than 60 million cases in the US alone and more than 12k died… There were more than 175k (low end estimates) who died World Wide from the H1N1.
And I think I’ve read that the CDC says there have been more than 6.4 million cases of the flu ins the US in 2020 with more than 2,900 deaths.
I think the constant bombardment and rehashing of the same information CoVID-19 Virus every 15 minutes has caused people to panic. I’d rather have one time each day that the country is brought up to speed on the events of this illness.
Bud and others, I have read your comments about this virus is not comparable to previous flus. If we do not social distance and take this seriously we will see numbers that far surpass previous flu epidemics. Take this seriously! Practice social distancing!
Joyce, what I glean from Dr. Oz is Covid 19 has a mortality rate 10 times greater than the flu. Also, people can have the virus but be symptom-free unlike the flu which almost always produces symptoms in everybody who has it. So there is a greater risk that Covid 19 can be unknowingly spread to vulnerable people.
Healthcare experts are afraid that the healthcare system could be quickly overwhelmed, much more so than with the flu.
Joyce, I am not trying compare past to present with my comment, rather to to try and show we’ve had other very bad illness without the hording or the panic that is taking place now.
We agree on the need to take this seriously, even to social distance but to panic in any situation causes folks to not think rationally.
I just think we need to pause before we react, try and look at the the whole picture and all the parts our decisions touch.
Ask do I really need 100 rolls of toilet paper or would 30 hold me so my community/neighbor can get their 30 rolls as well.
or
If we close all the small business’s down, how do those folks pay for basic things like food , water , taxes. Lots of folks out there still live month to month.
What I think we need from our leaders is to provide accurate and timely information. so we can make educated decisions on what next steps for each person needs to be.
I still believe in the goodness of people, we just need to slow down for just a minute and believe this will get better.
Thanks Joyce…
Bud, I agree with you. We have always been a nation of compassion and caring for others. It’s time to act like it.
I agree Joyce, I think social distancing if not widely practiced is waisted. I also do not want my government telling me how to run my small business. That being said, I am voluntarily limiting my hours and doing business with minimal contact for my sake as well as my customers. It does take a village….
Well said