On Monday, February 9, 2015 the city hosted Round 1 of the “library war.” City staff presented its proposal to sell the Foothills Branch Library and relocate it to the Foothills Recreation and Aquatic Center (FRAC) to the citizen Parks and Recreation Commission.
The meeting took place at FRAC and there were estimates of 150 to 200 people in attendance. There were ordinary citizens standing out in front of the building handing out flyers about the proposed sale.
Mary and Patty, two readers of my blog, kindly shared some observations of the meeting:
- “Many people who use the FRAC were in attendance and they were not happy campers.”
- “At a time when the FRAC is trying to beef up their membership, this endeavor would mean cutting many programs and farming out some programs to other locations. People pay a membership to FRAC but will have to go to another location for weightlifting, dancing, table tennis, etc.”
- “There is a lot of running around and noise generated from the children using the pool during summer hours; a library is supposed to be a quiet place.”
- “Children should have the experience of reading and handling books.”
- “From a realtor: ‘this is not a good time to be selling. It’s a buyer’s market’.”
- One person challenged the picture showing many rows of books in the meeting room we were in. She asked if this had been drawn to scale. Eric Strunk answered, ‘No, it’s just our perception of what the room will look like’.”
- “The head of the Parks and Recreation Commission asked excellent questions and all members were actively listening and questioning.”
- “Concerns were also raised about harming the integrity of the programs offered and expected by the Rec center patrons and that the pool table area is actually the only area youth that could not afford to join could freely use.”
- A man shared how he bought his home because of the proximity of the library.”
- “Several promises have been made by Midwestern but once a sale is made there is nothing to keep them from selling the dog parks, etc.”
- Once sold, the Foothills library is not intended to be used as a library but rather as a study area.”
- It was said by staff that less books were being checked out but a woman who is a library volunteer shared that would be expected since library hours and days have significantly decreased.”
From the comments offered you get the idea. There were a lot of difficult questions for staff with less than satisfactory answers. Staff promised to look into the many questions and to offer complete answers online at the city’s website.
Round 2 of the “library war” is:
- TONIGHT, Wednesday, February 11, 2015 at 6 PM
- at the Foothills Branch Library, Coyote Room
The same presentation will be made before the Library Advisory Board with the same opportunity for citizen comments. Seating will probably be at a premium. A word to the wise, come early to guarantee yourself a seat. Let’s outdo the attendance figure of the Monday night meeting. It’s no longer a matter of just saving Foothills library but it also includes preserving the programs and the space needed to conduct them at FRAC as well.
© Joyce Clark, 2015
FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which is in accordance with Title 17 U.S. C., Section 107. The material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democratic, scientific and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law and who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use,’ you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Thanks again, Joyce, for the update.
So many good points brought up at that meeting. It’s hard to believe that the sale of the Foothills Branch Library would ever go through, when there is so much that is wrong about the proposal.
The negative impact to programs for both the FBL and FRAC far outweigh the positive.
I just had a thought this morning:
Have any of the local television stations been informed of this “Library War” in Glendale?
It would make for an interesting news item, and reach those who may not have heard about the situation by now.
A few t.v. cameras at the next meeting might help “our cause”.
I believe Channel 12 had a camera at Monday night meeting.
Yes, Channel 12 did have a camera at Monday’s meeting. I was there and spoke against the sale.
One thing not mentioned in many of the articles and blogs I’ve seen so far is how limited the electronic books are compared to the library itself. Mostly it has authors most recent 2-4 books. So if you find an author you’ve never read before, you can check out their latest few books on an e-reader, but you have to go to the library to find any of their earlier books. Since the intent seems to be to keep those books that are checked out the most, these books will all be discarded.
Many of the electronic books are not available in ebook format, only in audio format. I don’t process audio well, so that’s means those books are not really available to me.
The browsing capability of the electronic catalogue is awful. I can much more easily go to the library, start down some row at random and just skim books titles and authors. You can’t really start browsing the electronic catalogue from somewhere in the middle, even if you’ve applied some filters. You can only jump forward 2 pages at a time and you have to wait for each page to load. Sometimes online is not faster or more convenient. Online is great if you want a recently published book and you know exactly what you want.
From what I’ve seen and heard, they might just as well call this new entity the “Foothills Technology Center” and just drop the library word. That seems to be what we’d be getting.
quote Anne Sullivan:
“…From what I’ve seen and heard, they might just as well call this new entity the “Foothills Technology Center” and just drop the library word. That seems to be what we’d be getting.”
The more I read about this proposal/relocation, the more depressed I become. ( 🙁 sigh)